Author (s): Angie Marcela Páez Monroy (LinkedIn)
Abstract
The K-pop industry has experienced an unexpected revival in physical album sales despite the dominance of digital music platforms. In the early 2000s, the rise of piracy and digital distribution significantly reduced demand for physical music formats, leading to a decline in album sales. However, K-pop companies have redefined the role of physical albums by transforming them into collectible cultural products. This article explores how album design, multiple versions, and the inclusion of random photocards influence the purchasing behavior of fans, particularly among younger generations. Drawing on existing literature about fan engagement and collectible culture, the article discusses how these strategies encourage bulk buying and strengthen emotional connections between fans and artists. At the same time, it raises environmental concerns related to mass production and the disposal of album materials when fans primarily collect photocards. The study highlights the need to consider more sustainable approaches while maintaining the strong fan engagement that has contributed to the resurgence of physical album sales in the K-pop industry.
Keywords: K-pop; physical albums; photocards; fan culture; music marketing; collectible culture; consumer behavior; sustainability
Introduction
The early 2000s were a difficult period for the global music industry. The rise of digital music and widespread piracy caused a sharp decline in physical album sales. In Korea, the industry for physical records, or eumban (음반), nearly disappeared, except for a few popular K-pop artists (National Folk Museum of Korea, 2025, p. 15).
Today, however, the situation has changed. K-pop companies have successfully revived physical album sales by transforming them into collectible products. Album design, multiple versions, and the inclusion of random photocards have become strategic tools to encourage fans to purchase physical copies. This shift is especially noticeable among younger generations, who engage with albums not only for music but also as a way to connect emotionally with their favorite artists (An et al., 2025).
1. From Music Storage to Collectible Products
Physical albums in the K-pop industry have evolved from mere music carriers to collectible objects. Companies now release multiple versions of the same album with different packaging, encouraging fans to buy more than one copy. Furthermore, albums often include random photocards featuring K-pop artists, whose rarity adds excitement and collectibility for fans (Rashidi, 2025, p. 14).
As the National Folk Museum of Korea explains, these strategies “have transformed albums from musical storage media for people to listen to, into a type of character product for fans to collect” (National Folk Museum of Korea, 2025, p. 15). The combination of visual design, collectible items, and fan engagement has made physical albums desirable again, despite the convenience of streaming.
2. The Role of Photocards in Fan Engagement
Photocards play a central role in this resurgence. Fans often purchase albums specifically to collect these items, which resemble trading cards in both design and rarity (Groh, 2025; Rashidi, 2025, p. 14). This practice encourages multiple purchases, bulk buying, and trading among fans. Such behavior is not unique to K-pop; vinyl record collectors of various genres also show a similar willingness to purchase physical formats to support artists and deepen their engagement (Brown & Knox).
The appeal of photocards is closely tied to emotional attachment. K-pop fans develop strong connections with their favorite artists, which motivates them to engage in collectible behaviors as a way of expressing fandom (An et al., 2025). Glasser (2023) also notes that certain fan bases, such as country and K-pop listeners, are particularly drawn to physical CDs, emphasizing the role of fan loyalty in driving sales.
3. A Revival in Sales
These marketing strategies have produced remarkable results. BTS’s fifth mini-album LOVE YOURSELF 承 ‘Her’ (2017) became the first K-pop album in 16 years to sell over one million copies, since g.o.d in 2001 (National Folk Museum of Korea, 2025, p. 15). In 2023, 35 K-pop albums each sold over a million copies, demonstrating a strong resurgence in the physical album market (National Folk Museum of Korea, 2025, p. 15).
The use of collectible items and creative album design has clearly turned physical albums into desirable cultural products, showing that even in the digital age, tangible items can create value and strengthen fan engagement.
4. Environmental Concerns and Reflection
Despite their success, these strategies raise environmental concerns. Many fans focus on collecting photocards while discarding or gifting the remaining album content, creating waste from materials produced mainly for bulk buying. This trend suggests that while albums are culturally significant, their mass production may not be environmentally sustainable.
The growing popularity of physical albums invites an important question for the future: how can the K-pop industry continue to engage fans with creative album designs and collectibles while reducing waste and promoting sustainability? Exploring eco-friendly packaging, digital-physical hybrids, or alternative collectible formats could help balance commercial success with environmental responsibility.
REFERENCES
An, B. J., Jung, S. H., Ahn, G. H., & Kim, J. H. (2025). The Process by Which BTS’s Star Attributes Lead to Loyalty Through Global Fans’ Need Fulfillment and Satisfaction: Implications for Tourism Marketing. Tourism and Hospitality 2025, Vol. 6, Page 126, 6(3), 126. https://doi.org/10.3390/tourhosp6030126
Brown, Steven; Knox, D. (n.d.). Why buy an album? The motivations behind recorded music purchases. https://doi.org/10.1037/pmu0000134
Glasser, Z. (2023). The CD Finds New Life Among Gen Z Collectors. The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/entertainment/2023/08/19/gen-z-collectors-love-the-cd/
National Folk Museum of Korea. (2025). Encyclopedia of Hallyu. Jang Sang-hoon (Director General, National Folk Museum of Korea). https://folkency.nfm.go.kr/
Rashidi, W. (2025). Photocards and Collections: The Appeal, Popularity, and Uses of K-pop Compact Disc Purchases in the United States. Journal of the Music and Entertainment Industry Educators Association, 25(1), 12–19. https://doi.org/10.2478/meiea-2025-0004
Convocatoria de contribuciones – Haneul Research Blog
Recibimos contribuciones académicas relacionadas con los estudios coreanos, incluyendo temas como literatura, música, industrias culturales, ciencia, innovación y otros campos afines.
Investigadores, académicos y estudiantes interesados en contribuir pueden enviar sus trabajos siguiendo las siguientes indicaciones:
Requisitos de envío
Por favor envíe un archivo en formato Word que incluya la siguiente información:
- Autor(es)
- Palabras clave en español e inglés
- Resumen (abstract)
- Contenido del artículo
El manuscrito debe:
- Incluir al menos cinco citas o referencias académicas
- Tener una extensión entre 2 y 5 páginas
- Estar escrito en inglés o en español
Los textos enviados serán revisados antes de su publicación. Estos pueden ser enviados al correo haneulssem@gmail.com.
Call for Contributions – Haneul Research Blog
We welcome academic contributions related to Korean Studies, including topics such as literature, music, cultural industries, science, innovation, and other related fields.
Researchers, scholars, and students interested in contributing are invited to submit their work following these guidelines:
Submission requirements
Please send a Word document including the following information:
- Author(s)
- Keywords in Spanish and English
- Abstract
- Main text
The manuscript should:
- Include at least five academic references or citations
- Have a length between 2 and 5 pages
- Be written in English or Spanish
Submissions will be reviewed before publication. You can submit the file to haneulssem@gmail.com.